When you hear Cuban music...

topic posted Fri, January 13, 2006 - 1:53 PM by  Unsubscribed
how does it make you feel?
posted by:
Unsubscribed
  • Re: When you hear Cuban music...

    Fri, January 13, 2006 - 2:05 PM
    Excellent question!

    Happy. Like there is hope. With as nuts as everything else is right now in our world, like there is still hope.

    And, humble. The sophistication of the music is awe inspiring and the level at which Cuban musicians play is an inspiration to musicians everywhere.

    And, like I want to party. :-)
    • Re: When you hear Cuban music...

      Sun, January 15, 2006 - 9:26 AM
      it makes me feel light...
      also amiration- for the cuban people, the talent, the tradition, the culture...
      it makes me feel strong in a way.
      but also humble.
      and then I want to dance.
  • Unsu...
     

    Re: When you hear Cuban music...

    Tue, January 17, 2006 - 12:32 AM
    I disagree. That wasn't a good question at all!

    What type of Cuban music ? We have danson and mambo, rumba and guaguanco, montuno and guajira, vieja and nueva trova to mention a few of the most commonly known genres.

    "When you hear American, music..." That wouldn't be a good question at all either.


    But in order to fill the blank and complete the sentence... When I hear Cuban music I feel cocky.
    • Re: When you hear Cuban music...

      Tue, January 17, 2006 - 6:52 AM
      <<<I disagree. That wasn't a good question at all!>>>

      I'll stand by what I said. I like it all. Whether it is a commercial salsa tune from Maraca y Otra Vision or a fokloric style from Munequitos de Matanzas. It makes me feel how I said it did. I'll reserve the right to feel that way. Gringo or not. It's just my own, personal feeling on it and I get to have that.

      Braulio, you say you have "Rumba AND Guaguanco". That statement puzzles me. The Cubanos I've studied with have taught me that Guanguanco IS rumba. As is Columbia and Yambu. Three parts to that family that makes up Rumba. Can you explain how Guanguanco is different than Rumba? I'm always trying to learn more.

      I don't think there is anything wrong with the question "When you hear American music" either. The question will just evoke different responses from people with different experiences. I can think of emotions I felt when I first heard a Miles Davis tune that were similar to the feelings I had when I first heard the melody to a Roots tune. Perhaps it is the African influence that runs so deep in these styles that connects the dots. Don't know. I'm not an Ethno-Musicoligist. I'm just a drummer. To take it to an extreme; I remember being blown away by Run DMC lyrics (a long time ago) and it reminded me of rather profound insight that I thought was present in the lyrics of a Hank William's (the original) tune. Not the same message by any means but similar, in an American mongrel sense. The message in both tunes was like "here we all are, together, how are we going to make this work?". So, Hank lived from 1923 to 1953 (I hope that is close) and Run DMC was an emerging rap group in the 1980's. The message in the lyric struck me as being similar. Yeah, I think a question about "how does American music make you feel", is permissable. Of course, you can break it down by genres and time frames, age groups, demographics, etc. and debate the issue to death. But I happen to like the spirit in which I think the orginal question was asked.

      This is interesting huh? An American responds to a question about Cuban music and a Cuban tells the American it's a bad question. Then the Cuban states that a generalized question about American music is no good either and the American tells him that the question is OK too.

      I love the tribe. Salud, Braulio.
      • Re: When you hear Cuban music...

        Wed, January 18, 2006 - 10:52 AM
        I've been pondering this question for a few days to find something original. But all I can say is that there is a warmth to the Cuban sound, (for me anyway). I can usually tell when a song is by a Cuban group, when I'm in a Latin club, there is something unique about it, a flavor that you don't find in say Puerto Rican Salsa. Also Cuban music brings back memories of when I've travelled there and the way the place affects you. Everyone I know that has gone to Cuba has always come back with a love for the country, the people, and the music. Most of them are women, but maybe that's because I know more women, but I digress. Cuban music feels like a party, where everyone's invited and everyone's happy. I can't find the words to explain what I want to say, it's something about togetherness. It will come to me, for now this is what I think.
      • Unsu...
         

        Re: When you hear Cuban music...

        Wed, January 18, 2006 - 4:45 PM
        Chu - I noticed how some of the responses were gravitating around the element of dancing, which is not necessarily present in all Cuban music genres. It made me wonder how much people in this tribe really knew about Cuban music. So, I decided to throw a 'note of discordance' into the discussion to force people into thinking beyond that form of Cuban music re-introduced in the American market/audience by Buena Vista Social Club a few years ago. I was hoping to get more interesting answers other than dancing. I’m glad you did. Don’t get me wrong; dancing was also a valid answer. I hope I didn't get in trouble for my reply!

        I really don’t know what are the technical differences between a Rumba and a Guaganco. Maybe the music experts group them together as part of the same family but for the average dude like me they sound quite distinctive one from another. To me, Guaganco is the drumming that takes place in the backyard of a common Cuban home and it could be performed with a single bata drum, whereas Rumba is like a more complex drumming performance where different type of drums call each other alternatively. I don’t know if you are familiar with the ‘Papines,’ three famous African-Cuban drummers who did this kind of drumming. When I think of Rumba I think of them.

        Peace.
        • Re: When you hear Cuban music...

          Wed, January 18, 2006 - 6:12 PM
          Oi Braulio, Los Papines, the Abreu brothers, right? Yes, I know of thier work. You know, this could become a very complicated thread, now! I must be very careful not to try to speak beyond my means but I will venture a little further out on the subject of Rumba. What is the worse that can happen? I will be corrected and then I will know more about a subject that is not so easy to learn about in the US.

          So when I think of Rumba, I do think of it first in the folkloric sense. Groups such as Munequitos de Matanzas, Yoruba Andabo, and Afro-Cuba de Matanzas. And within this family of rumba there is yambu- slower, maybe for the older folks, guaguanco- maybe younger and sexier and columbia- faster, rhythms in 6/8, athletic even. And this music is for interacting with the orichas. I think I should stop there. I may have offended someone already!

          Next I think about how a sacred music such as Rumba can influence a culture and wonder if something like guaguanco was popularized in more secular settings. For example, I am not a truly trained bata drummer but I can play different forms of guaguanco on the congas. Two congas or three congas, guaguanco matanzas style or guaguanco Habana style.

          So, in my simple mind guaguanco in a traditional sense exists within the Rumba family. And, a different form of guaguanco may exist as a rhythm that you may here played within a modern line up such Maraca y otra Vision or in a group like Geraldo Piloto's, Klimax.

          Ha ha... now for my own punch line... I read what I just wrote above and think what a typical American condition I have; the tendency to have to slap a label on everything, paint it into a corner like it can only be understood as how we define it here. It makes me think back to the days when I was studying with my friend Yorvanis from Habana- after too many questions from me he would get frustrated and say "Man, you think too much. Just play and dance. You'll understand more by the experience than by all your questions". Smart dude that Yorvanis!

          I hope there is some truth to my understanding because I have worked hard to learn about these things. It's very hard to find people in the US that can appreciate the beauty and importance of these art forms. You folks in and around San Francisco are blessed with communites of people that know this. In my part of the country you have to learn from scraps.

          So Braulio, I saw a challenge in your original post on this. I'm glad you posted what you did. It made me think a little harder, again. But I still say that when I hear "Cuban" music it makes me happy, gives me hope and makes me want to party.

          Cheers!
          • Unsu...
             

            Re: When you hear Cuban music...

            Thu, January 19, 2006 - 1:30 PM
            Chu, I don’t know much about this kind of music and maybe I should since it is part of Cuban culture. I grew up in Habana and I’m able to recognize these rythms but other than that I don’t know much more about them. I’m ashamed.

            I think you are right about guaguanco. I agree with you that it is a type of secular drumming and dancing not linked to the sacred Yoruba music. As to Rumba, according the way you describe it, sounds more like what I call ‘santeria’s music’. For example, for me the music of Lazaro Ró is a ‘santeria’s music’. Are you familiar with him? And if so, is that music what you call Rumba...?

            Regards,

            Braulio.

            • Re: When you hear Cuban music...

              Thu, January 19, 2006 - 7:11 PM
              As I recall, the original question was : How does Cuban music make you "feel"? I am aware that Los Van Van and Buena Vista is not all there is and I may not be able to put a name to the rythyms, but I still maintain that there is a warmth to the music And very often it makes me feel like dancing, cos as a dancer, I can pretty much dance to anything.

              p.s but your discussions are informative
      • Re: When you hear Cuban music...

        Fri, February 24, 2006 - 7:34 PM
        guaguanco is different thatn rumba in the way the shoulders move, guaguanco goes like 1-1-3-2 y 1-3-2-1, la rumba va 3-2-2, 3-2-2-1 and then it repeats 3 times, Guaguanco repeats on the 8th beat.

        Hope it helps.
        • Re: When you hear Cuban music...

          Wed, March 8, 2006 - 12:03 PM
          when i hear son or timba, i feel this deep peace, yet like dancing. Ecstatic. I listen to adalberto alvarez as i write this and god, it's gonna be hard to stay home and do homework tonite rather than go out and dance. Maybe just for a little while...

          It makes me feel in love with the world.